The breadth of thermal tolerance delineates the upper (CTmax/Tuc) and lower (CTmin/Tlc) temperatures relevant to survival and/or persistence of organisms, and it is a correlate of extinction risk under climate change. Theory suggests that tolerance breadth evolves with the range of environmental temperatures. For instance, a narrow tolerance breadth is classically observed in tropical vs temperate species, and tropical ectotherms may feature increased extinction risk under climate change due to the proximity of CTmax and mean environmental temperatures. Here, we underscore that an organism’s lifestyle influences the extent of thermal fluctuation in its environment. We predict that subterranean species feature a narrower thermal tolerance breadth than surface-dwelling species, as the former evolve under dampened thermal variance. Using thermal limits data, we test this hypothesis in reptiles, mammals, and arthropods. Subterranean species (n = 5 – 37 per taxon) featured reduced tolerance breadths compared to surface-dwelling species, and the difference was significant in reptiles and mammals; additionally, subterranean arthropods featured a significantly lower CTmax and significantly higher CTmin than surface species. Thus, classical theory on thermal tolerance extends beyond patterns of geolocation to species lifestyle, where evolution under dampened thermal variance can reduce thermal tolerance breadth and influence other thermal traits.